One-page Checkout Vs. Multi-page Checkout: Which is Better to Increase Conversions?  

Skai Lama
November 24, 2023

The structure of your checkout flow can be a decisive factor in the success of your eCommerce conversions. A well-structured checkout flow not only simplifies the purchase journey but also significantly reduces cart abandonment rates.  

In this post, we delve into the two predominant strategies, one-page vs. multi-page checkout, to understand which is more effective in optimizing conversions.

What is a One-Page Checkout? 

The one-page checkout model simplifies the purchasing journey by consolidating all steps into a single, streamlined page. This approach is designed to make the checkout process more efficient and user-friendly. 

Let's look at the advantages and disadvantages of implementing a one-page checkout system:

Pros of One-Page Checkout

1. Reduced Checkout Time

The one-page checkout significantly accelerates the purchase process. Compared to the average 1:40 minutes required for a multi-page checkout, a one-page system can trim this down to just 53 seconds.

This reduction in time not only enhances the user experience but also plays a crucial role in improving conversion rates, as customers appreciate and respond positively to a quicker checkout experience.

2. Fewer Clicks Required

By condensing the checkout process into a single page, the number of clicks and interactions required from the customer is significantly reduced. This streamlined approach not only makes the process faster but also more convenient, as customers can enter all their details in one go without having to navigate through multiple pages. 

The reduction in clicks also means there's less chance for customers to second-guess their purchase, leading to a smoother transaction.

3. Highly Intuitive Design

Presenting all the necessary checkout steps on one page makes the process inherently intuitive. Customers can see the entirety of their checkout journey at a glance, which helps understand how far they have progressed and what's left to do. This clarity in navigation can greatly reduce confusion and hesitation, contributing to a more positive user experience and potentially higher conversion rates.

4. Minimizes Cart Abandonment

One of the key advantages of a one-page checkout is its ability to reduce cart abandonment rates. With every step and requirement clearly visible on a single page, customers are less likely to get frustrated or overwhelmed, which are common reasons for abandoning carts. The simplicity and transparency of seeing everything at once reassure customers, encouraging them to complete their purchase.

Cons of One-Page Checkout

1. Risk of Overwhelming Customers

One of the main drawbacks of a one-page checkout is the potential to overwhelm customers with too much information at once. When a checkout page is densely packed with numerous fields and options, it can lead to confusion and frustration, particularly for customers who prefer a more guided and segmented approach. This overwhelming experience can be counterintuitive to the checkout's primary goal of simplifying the process. 

Therefore, it's essential to carefully design one-page checkouts to ensure they are intuitive and user-friendly without bombarding customers with an overload of information that could deter them from completing their purchases.

2. Limited Analytical Insights

A one-page checkout can pose challenges for in-depth analytics, especially for businesses that rely on tools like Google Analytics to track customer behavior through the checkout process. In a multi-page setup, it’s easier to identify at which specific step customers drop off, allowing for targeted improvements.

However, with a one-page checkout, this granularity in data is lost. As all actions take place on a single page, it becomes more challenging to pinpoint where customers decide to abandon their carts and why. This lack of detailed analytical data can hinder the optimization process and make it more difficult to refine the checkout experience based on customer behavior.

Also Read: Everything you need to know about Shopify Checkout Customisation

What is Multi-Step Checkout? 

A multi-page or multi-step checkout divides the checkout process into distinct steps and pages, guiding customers through a series of actions to complete their purchase.

Pros of a Multi-Page Checkout

1. Enhanced Customer Control

The multi-page checkout design offers customers a greater degree of control over their purchasing process. By breaking down the checkout into distinct stages, it allows customers to focus on one set of details at a time. 

This step-by-step approach not only minimizes the risk of input errors but also gives customers the opportunity to review and confirm information at each stage. As a result, customers feel more in control and assured that their order details are accurate, leading to a more satisfying purchase experience.

2. Improved Analytical Insights

Multi-page checkouts offer a distinct advantage when it comes to analytics and performance tracking. Tools like Google Analytics can be used more effectively in this setup to monitor customer behavior across different stages of the checkout process. 

This detailed analysis makes it easier for businesses to pinpoint exactly where customers are dropping off. Knowing which specific page or step has a higher abandonment rate allows for more targeted and efficient optimizations, potentially increasing overall conversion rates.

3. Opportunities to Re-engage Customers

One strategic benefit of a multi-step checkout is the early collection of customer contact information, usually in the initial steps. If a customer starts the checkout process but doesn't complete their purchase, the gathered information (such as email addresses) can be utilized to re-engage them. 

Follow-up emails can be sent to these customers, reminding them of their incomplete purchase or offering assistance, thus providing a chance to recover potentially lost sales. This proactive approach to re-engagement can be a key factor in boosting conversions and enhancing customer relations.

Cons of a Multi-Page Checkout

1. Time-Consuming Nature

A significant downside of multi-page checkouts is the extended time it takes to complete a transaction. Each additional page or step in the process adds to the overall duration, which can test the patience of customers.

In today's fast-paced digital environment, where speed is often equated with efficiency, the prolonged nature of multi-step checkouts can lead to higher instances of cart abandonment. Customers, particularly those accustomed to quick online transactions, might find the extended process tedious and may lose interest midway, moving on to other tasks or websites.

2. User Experience (UX) Challenges

From a user experience standpoint, multi-page checkouts present several potential hurdles. Customers often have to navigate through multiple pages to enter or modify information, which can be especially cumbersome if they need to make changes to previously entered details, like adjusting their shipping address or adding special instructions.

This back-and-forth navigation can not only be time-consuming but also frustrating, diminishing the overall quality of the user experience. Such UX challenges can be particularly off-putting for new or less tech-savvy customers, who might find the process confusing and, consequently, are more likely to abandon their carts.

One Page Checkout vs. Multi-page Checkout: Comparison

Feature One Page Checkout Multi-Page Checkout
Conversions Generally higher conversion rates. Potentially lower due to more steps in the process.
Clicks Fewer clicks needed, streamlining the process. More clicks required, increasing the chance of abandonment.
User Experience Streamlined but can be overwhelming with information. Divided into manageable steps, enhancing comfort and tracking.
Page Loading Speed Faster overall load times for the entire process. Initial page may load faster, but subsequent steps add time.
Checkout Time Typically quicker as all options are on one page. Slower due to navigating multiple pages for changes.
Data Analytics Challenging to pinpoint abandonment stages. Easier to identify at which step users drop off.

Deciding Between One-Page and Multi-Page Checkouts for Your Ecommerce Store

Choosing the right checkout style is crucial for optimizing your eCommerce store's conversion rates. Here's a breakdown to help you decide:

One-Page Checkout

  1. Ideal for Digital and Downloadable Products: For quick purchases like digital items, a one-page checkout streamlines the process by consolidating address and shipping details on a single page.
  2. Effective for Frequent Shoppers: Businesses with a high rate of returning customers or registered users who make regular purchases can benefit significantly from the convenience of a one-page checkout.
  3. Best Suited for Low-Cost Items: The simplicity and speed of one-page checkouts make them particularly effective for lower-cost products, where the decision-making process is typically quicker.

Multi-Page Checkout

  1. Optimal for High-Value Purchases: For items with a higher price tag or those requiring more thoughtful consideration, a multi-page checkout process can provide customers with the reassurance they need, breaking down the purchase into digestible steps.
  2. Boosts Customer Confidence: Allowing customers to review details like their order, delivery address, and pricing at each step enhances their confidence in the purchase, reducing the likelihood of cart abandonment.
  3. Crucial for Information Review: Implementing a design where customers can easily review and edit their information before proceeding ensures a smooth and reliable checkout experience.

Recommended Read: Everything about upgrading from checkout liquid to checkout extensibility

Wrapping up

Whether opting for a one-page or a multi-step checkout approach, the key objective remains the same: to facilitate a checkout experience that is both smooth and efficient, ultimately driving higher conversion rates.

For brands seeking an optimized checkout solution specifically tailored to Shopify stores, exploring Checkout Wiz by Skailama could be a game-changer. The app is designed to help you customize your checkout page for maximum conversions.

But that’s not all, our checkout optimization also opens up new opportunities to help you sell more to an engaged visitor, thereby increasing your average order value and business revenue!ewew3

To optimize your Shopify checkout to it's full extent, you need to migrate your Shopify Checkout from Checkout.liquid to Checkout.extensions. Here's a easy 6 step process for you to migrate your Checkout right away:

Boost Sales with Upselling!
Boost your Shopify sales and profits with strategic upselling and cross-selling. Enhance AOV and retention. Book a call!
1. Strategic upsell campaigns
2. Enhance AOV & retention
No items found.